| Platinum | Cucina Toscana |
| Gold | Luks Bar and Grill |
| Silver | Pizzico |
| Bronze | Mike's Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Fulchino's Vineyard |
| Top Pick | Luciano's Italian |
| Top Pick | Lui Lui |
| Top Pick | Tammaro's Cucina |
| Top Pick | The Peddler's Daughter |
| Top Pick | Valentino's Italian Cafe, Pizzeria, & Bakery |