| Platinum | Jeannotte's Market |
| Gold | Bill Cahill's Super Subs |
| Silver | Market Basket |
| Bronze | T J's Deli Catering Pizza and Subs |
| Top Pick | Bagel Alley |
| Top Pick | Cedars Cafe |
| Top Pick | Christophers Subs & Pizza |
| Top Pick | Dannelly's Pizza & Subs |
| Top Pick | Mike's Pie |
| Top Pick | Nashua Garden |