| Platinum | Bittersweet Bake Shoppe |
| Gold | Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream |
| Silver | Timeless Treats Ice Cream Trucks |
| Bronze | Crosby Bakery |
| Top Pick | Dutch Epicure Bakery |
| Top Pick | Frederick's Pastries |
| Top Pick | Mike's Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Soel Sistas |
| Top Pick | Sullivan Farms Homemade Ice Cream |