| Platinum | Sopranos Pizzeria |
| Gold | Bob's Pizza and Subs |
| Silver | Mike's Pie |
| Bronze | Not Your Average Joe's |
| Top Pick | Giovanni's Roastbeef & Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Kendall Pond Pizza |
| Top Pick | Maplewood Pizza Seafood |
| Top Pick | Pizzeria Regina |
| Top Pick | Rocco's Pizza Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | T J's Deli Catering Pizza and Subs |